Once I had a Comrade
ISBN: 1 874622 58 2
Reviewer: Dan K.
Review Date: 12 Jun 2008
I came across this memoir at the book store, and only purchased it after speaking to a friend about it. Upon reading it, I'm not disappointed.
The book is written by the son-in-law of Karl Roth, who was a tank maintenence soldier. It covers the combat history of the 36th Panzer Regiment during the war. The book is broken down into 5 parts from before the war to after the war, with a few chapters in each part. Everything from the first attacks in Poland and France, through the Balkans, and the battles in Russia are covered, including Stalingrad. The Regiment ended up in the Courland Pocket which I found very interesting as I have not read too many memoirs from this theatre. All 6 battles are covered with how the 36th Regiment was employed and the ultimate fate of "battle groups" that end up getting fragmented off. There are enough "first person" accounts of fellow soldiers to keep the reader well informed of what was really happening. The book is well covered in photos from both the Bundsarchive and fellow soldiers, including many that I have never seen before.
I did find the book did jump around a bit with the story of Karl Roth, then it goes to his friends and then back to the unit then back to Karl. This in no way detracts from the book but did, at times, cause it to not "flow" smoothly.
It is more a unit history than a memoir. Nevertheless, it is still highly recommended as both a memoir (as it is called) and definitely as an unit history.
Back to Main | Back to Book Reviews Index
![]() |


Advertise on ww2db.com
- » 527 biographies
- » 215 events
- » 519 ships
- » 209 aircraft models
- » 100 vehicle models
- » 204 weapon models
- » 31 historical documents
- » 133 book reviews
- » 7605 photos, 860 in color
Winston Churchill, 1935

Share this article with your friends:
Stay updated with WW2DB: