Caption | Major General Manton Eddy and another American officer speaking to a captured German officer, Cherbourg, France, 26-27 Jun 1944 ww2dbase | ||||||||
Photographer | Unknown | ||||||||
Source | ww2dbaseWikimedia Commons | ||||||||
Link to Source | Link | ||||||||
More on... |
| ||||||||
Photo Size | 1,582 x 1,240 pixels | ||||||||
Photos on Same Day | 27 Jun 1944 | ||||||||
Photos at Same Place | Cherbourg, Basse-Normandie, France | ||||||||
Added By | C. Peter Chen | ||||||||
Licensing | This work is believed to be in the public domain. Please contact us regarding any inaccuracies with the above information. Thank you. |
Did you enjoy this photograph or find this photograph helpful? If so, please consider supporting us on Patreon. Even $1 per month will go a long way! Thank you. Share this photograph with your friends: Stay updated with WW2DB: |
Visitor Submitted Comments
2. Anonymous says:
27 Jun 2014 12:52:11 PM
I disagree - the uniform looks nothing like "something from the future". It looks like a throwback. The American uniforms have none of the pretentiousness shown by the German uniforms. They are combat uniforms meant for combat.
27 Jun 2014 12:52:11 PM
I disagree - the uniform looks nothing like "something from the future". It looks like a throwback. The American uniforms have none of the pretentiousness shown by the German uniforms. They are combat uniforms meant for combat.
3. Bill says:
23 Dec 2014 05:33:20 PM
SURRENDER TERMS: CALLING THE SHOTS
The German officer asked the American, as an officer and gentlemen, what is your word on surrender terms. The American officer thinks for a second, and responds with.
Oh, I've given you no word. In my judgement you simply have no alternative.
23 Dec 2014 05:33:20 PM
SURRENDER TERMS: CALLING THE SHOTS
The German officer asked the American, as an officer and gentlemen, what is your word on surrender terms. The American officer thinks for a second, and responds with.
Oh, I've given you no word. In my judgement you simply have no alternative.
4. Bill says:
26 Dec 2014 10:37:09 AM
THE FATHERLAND'S MILITARY AWARDS:
Above file photo shows German soldier wearing various medals and awards. Sir looks like he's won a lot of prizes, and he's taking a one way ticket back to headquarters after the surrender.
Let's see what they are. He's been awarded the Iron Cross, badge to right of Iron Cross is the assault badge, below the Iron Cross is the wound badge awarded for wounds in action.
I can't identify the ribbons he's wearing, his field gray uniform is the M36 pattern with dark green collar and looks like he's been issued a pre M1943 steel helmet w/rolled over rim also at this late stage of the war, helmet eagle and tri color decals have long been deleted.
His rank looks like that of a captain I see two pips on his shoulder straps this offices serves with the (Heer) the German Army.
GI ISSUE:
Officer in center of photo, is a Major General showing two stars, stars also show upon his shoulder straps. M-1 helmet and what looks like a GI cold weather overcoat. I can't identify what rank the other officer is or what he's wearing.
SURRENDER PROTOCAL:
Is Major General Eddy accepting the surrender of
the German Captain, using the unidentified U.S. Officer as interpreter. Or is the General having the German surrender to an Officer of similar rank, and than accepts the enemy's surrender?
GI JOE:
No doubt the German Officer in above photograph carried a white flag so he could pass without harm through American lines, and speak to U.S. Officers. The Germans were obsessed with symbols of rank and awards on their uniforms, more than Allied troops were. The only other ones who wore medals on their combat uniforms were the Russians
I'm sure some surrenders were carried out and the German officer was surprised to learn that the GI he was talking to, turned out to be a officer, rather than a PFC.
The American GI wanted to get the job done, and go home. During my tours in Vietnam, I've seen officers who didn't ware their rank in the field
for obvious reasons. If I've missed anything post it here at ww2db.
26 Dec 2014 10:37:09 AM
THE FATHERLAND'S MILITARY AWARDS:
Above file photo shows German soldier wearing various medals and awards. Sir looks like he's won a lot of prizes, and he's taking a one way ticket back to headquarters after the surrender.
Let's see what they are. He's been awarded the Iron Cross, badge to right of Iron Cross is the assault badge, below the Iron Cross is the wound badge awarded for wounds in action.
I can't identify the ribbons he's wearing, his field gray uniform is the M36 pattern with dark green collar and looks like he's been issued a pre M1943 steel helmet w/rolled over rim also at this late stage of the war, helmet eagle and tri color decals have long been deleted.
His rank looks like that of a captain I see two pips on his shoulder straps this offices serves with the (Heer) the German Army.
GI ISSUE:
Officer in center of photo, is a Major General showing two stars, stars also show upon his shoulder straps. M-1 helmet and what looks like a GI cold weather overcoat. I can't identify what rank the other officer is or what he's wearing.
SURRENDER PROTOCAL:
Is Major General Eddy accepting the surrender of
the German Captain, using the unidentified U.S. Officer as interpreter. Or is the General having the German surrender to an Officer of similar rank, and than accepts the enemy's surrender?
GI JOE:
No doubt the German Officer in above photograph carried a white flag so he could pass without harm through American lines, and speak to U.S. Officers. The Germans were obsessed with symbols of rank and awards on their uniforms, more than Allied troops were. The only other ones who wore medals on their combat uniforms were the Russians
I'm sure some surrenders were carried out and the German officer was surprised to learn that the GI he was talking to, turned out to be a officer, rather than a PFC.
The American GI wanted to get the job done, and go home. During my tours in Vietnam, I've seen officers who didn't ware their rank in the field
for obvious reasons. If I've missed anything post it here at ww2db.
5. Anonymous says:
28 Jun 2018 11:25:27 AM
Not a lot to say, the Germans had the sea to their backs surrender was obvious
28 Jun 2018 11:25:27 AM
Not a lot to say, the Germans had the sea to their backs surrender was obvious
All visitor submitted comments are opinions of those making the submissions and do not reflect views of WW2DB.
Search WW2DB
News
- » Wreck of USS Edsall Found (14 Nov 2024)
- » Autumn 2024 Fundraiser (7 Nov 2024)
- » Nobel Peace Prize for the Atomic Bomb Survivors Organization (11 Oct 2024)
- » Wreck of USS Stewart/DD-224 Found (2 Oct 2024)
- » See all news
Current Site Statistics
- » 1,150 biographies
- » 337 events
- » 43,917 timeline entries
- » 1,241 ships
- » 350 aircraft models
- » 207 vehicle models
- » 375 weapon models
- » 123 historical documents
- » 260 facilities
- » 470 book reviews
- » 28,545 photos
- » 432 maps
Famous WW2 Quote
"With Germany arming at breakneck speed, England lost in a pacifist dream, France corrupt and torn by dissension, America remote and indifferent... do you not tremble for your children?"Winston Churchill, 1935
Support Us
Please consider supporting us on Patreon. Even $1 a month will go a long way. Thank you!
Or, please support us by purchasing some WW2DB merchandise at TeeSpring, Thank you!
22 Oct 2013 07:11:34 AM
I'm no Nazi supporter, but *** that uniform... next to the American officers, it looks like something from the future.